Why More ‘A’s Don’t Necessarily Devalue the Currency

When people point to the greater number of students now getting ‘top grades’ in their exams and then they say this shows how Britain has ‘dumbed-down’ I am urged to remind them of the statistics on literacy. For example, the rate of literacy for Black females in the United States went from 30% to 70% in just forty years. Reading didn’t get easier; access to education was what changed in that time and hence, more people became better at reading. Similarly, a rise in people doing better in a test does not necessarily mean an unwarranted grade inflation, it can mean quite simply that more people know more things because we are teaching better.

The naysayers then say:  “But if everyone gets As then the whole purpose is devalued”. Well, only if you see the purpose of those exams as being about sifting people apart from one another.  Was reading suddenly devalued because twice as many people could do it?  No. Reading is a good thing in and of itself regardless of how many others do it. If one day 30% of people get an A on a reading test and four decades later 70% of people are getting that A, that is a good day for society. More people know how to read and have more flexibility with their future.

More people getting As is neither a sure-fire sign that standards have dropped nor that the A has become meaningless. If you wish to argue that more As is a bad thing, you need to do better than this.



Categories: Philosophy of Education, UK Education Policy

1 reply

  1. You have forgotten that a key part of Tory philosophy is that students should learn early on how to cope with failing.
    Failing is important to the elite because it is not something that happens to them. If everyone succeeds you cannot have an elite.

    Looking down on and belittling others is an important aspect of this methodology. Hence we have “private sector good, public sector bad”. “Comprehensives bad, Academies good”.

    More and more of the decision makers in British society are part of a closed elite. Law, media, medicine, politics, finance. Why would they want to change things?

    Unfortunately we have few politicians on the left who are able to articulate a better vision. Politicians on all sides seem only able to be just about OK at politics, and totally useless about the real world. Hence the great disenchantment with politicians amongst the general public. I vote for Michael Rosen to be next Prime Minister. Can we start a petition?

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 12,520 other followers

%d bloggers like this: